Tree risk assessment at the Certified Arborist level
Domain 8 of 10 · 11% of the exam
The Certified Arborist outline asks for the groundwork of tree risk: who answers for which decision, the ways a tree can cause harm, and a limited visual look at one tree or a street of them, followed by a sensible way to reduce the risk. This page keeps to what the Certified Arborist domain covers.
Answered 0 of 18 · 0 right
Question 1 of 18
An assessor recommends reinspecting a tree after one year rather than a longer interval. The MOST likely reason is that:
Reveal the key without answering
The interval should match how fast conditions are expected to change, and active decay can change the tree within a year.
The season of the visit can limit what was seen, but it does not mean the tree is changing faster.
Strong wood would argue for a longer interval, if anything.
Moving the target away lowers the risk, which supports a longer interval, not a shorter one.
Question 2 of 18
Which mitigation generally leaves NO residual risk from the tree?
Reveal the key without answering
Once the tree is removed there is no residual risk left: no part of it remains that could fail.
Support hardware lowers the chance of failure without removing the defect, and it needs inspection itself.
People can get past a fence and the tree keeps its defects, so some risk is always left.
Reduction lowers the load, but the tree and its defects remain and still need monitoring.
Question 3 of 18
Dense foliage kept an assessor from seeing the upper crown of a tree. In the report, the assessor should:
Reveal the key without answering
Anything that could not be seen is stated as a limitation, so the client can see where the rating stops.
Raising the rating by default is a guess about a condition that was not observed; a further inspection is the honest option.
Writing 'no defects' reports a finding that was never made, which misleads the client.
Silently leaving the crown out hides the gap instead of disclosing it.
Question 4 of 18
Which situation would receive the LOWEST risk rating?
Reveal the key without answering
When failure is improbable in the time frame, the matrix rates the risk low however busy the target is.
Even a possible failure over a busy stop can reach a moderate risk, above an improbable one.
A probable failure of a large part over a busy walk combines into a high risk.
An imminent trunk failure over occupied cars is among the highest ratings.
Question 5 of 18
Who decides the level of tree risk that is acceptable?
Reveal the key without answering
The person responsible for the tree weighs the risk against cost and value and chooses whether and how to reduce it.
The assessor rates the risk, explains it and recommends options, but the decision is not the assessor's to make.
Building inspectors deal with structures and codes, not with how much tree risk an owner accepts.
Crew members carry out the chosen work; they do not set how much risk a property may carry.
Question 6 of 18
A tree was rated for a one-year time frame. Two years later, with no reinspection, that rating:
Reveal the key without answering
A rating applies only for its stated time frame, because trees and sites change, so after it passes the tree needs a new assessment.
A rating has a time frame for a reason; treating it as open-ended ignores every change since the visit.
Storms are only one source of change; growth, new targets and new defects also make an old rating unreliable.
Ratings do not shift on a schedule; only a new assessment can say what the risk is now.
Question 7 of 18
Decay-detection devices such as sonic tomographs are MOST useful for:
Reveal the key without answering
Tomography and resistance drilling map how much solid wood is left in the stem, which helps judge strength loss.
Surface cracks are found by looking at the tree; the devices are for what cannot be seen.
These tools test the stem at the test points, not roots under paving.
Neither device names the fungus; that needs a conk or a sample sent to a lab.
Question 8 of 18
Photographs taken during a tree risk assessment are MOST valuable because they:
Reveal the key without answering
Dated photographs document what the tree looked like, so a later visit can tell whether a crack, lean or decay has changed.
The time frame is chosen by the assessor from the tree's condition, not by a photograph.
A rating needs the tree, the site and the targets in person; pictures leave out too much.
Photographs show only the surface; decay inside the stem needs sounding or a decay-detection device.
Question 9 of 18
A tree grown in a dense stand is suddenly exposed when nearby trees are removed. Its likelihood of failure increases MAINLY because it:
Reveal the key without answering
Sheltered trees grow little taper and anchorage because neighbors broke the wind, so sudden exposure loads them beyond what they built.
Sunscald can injure newly exposed bark; it does not cause the tree to fall.
A tree's anchorage comes mainly from its own structural roots, not from root grafts.
Added taper is the tree's slow answer that makes it more stable over time, not a cause of failure.
Question 10 of 18
Knowing that a species often fails at included-bark unions helps an assessor because it:
Reveal the key without answering
A species failure profile tells the assessor where that species tends to fail, so those parts get a closer look; the rating still rests on this tree.
A known weak point in the species is a reason to watch the tree more, not less.
Likelihood of impact depends on the target and how often it is present, not on the species.
Knowing where a species tends to fail says nothing about decay in this trunk, so the stem still has to be checked.
Question 11 of 18
Which defect is generally EASIER to see in leaf-off (dormant) conditions?
Reveal the key without answering
With the leaves off, the branch structure is open to view, so cracks, weak unions and cavities in the crown are easier to find.
Leaf color needs leaves, so it is a growing-season observation.
Wilting is a symptom of leaves; a dormant tree has none to show it.
Foliage density and leaf size can only be judged when the tree is in leaf.
Question 12 of 18
For each tree concern in a risk report, the assessor should clearly identify the:
Reveal the key without answering
Naming which part could fail, how it would fail and what it would strike tells the client exactly what each rating and each mitigation refers to.
These describe the tree in general; a rating is made for a specific part and target, so they do not identify the concern.
Budget is a business matter for later; it says nothing about what could fail or what it would hit.
Appraised value belongs to plant appraisal, a separate service, and does not describe the risk.
Question 13 of 18
A tree could block the only road to a hospital if it fell. Even though the road carries little traffic, the tree may be rated higher because of its:
Reveal the key without answering
Consequences include disruption of important services, not only injury and damage, so blocking the only hospital road raises them.
The tree's defects and loads set its likelihood of failure; the road it would block does not.
Light traffic means the road is seldom occupied, which would lower the rating, not raise it.
The time frame is the period the rating covers; it does not change with what the tree would hit.
Question 14 of 18
Which tree is MOST prone to windthrow?
Reveal the key without answering
Wet soil keeps roots shallow and loosens their grip, and many spruces root shallowly anyway, so this tree uproots most easily.
Short height and strong taper mean less leverage and a stem built for wind.
Deep roots in well-drained soil give strong anchorage.
A small crown catches little wind, so the overturning load is low.
Question 15 of 18
A sonic tomogram and resistance drilling give different estimates of decay in the same trunk. The assessor should:
Reveal the key without answering
Each method measures something different and has its own errors, so the results are checked against each other and what the tree shows.
Picking the more favorable reading understates the risk.
Averaging hides the reason the readings differ.
Sounding gives less information than either device.
Question 16 of 18
Low limbs over a street are regularly struck by trucks. This risk is BEST addressed by:
Reveal the key without answering
Removing or shortening the low limbs gives vehicles clearance and stops the repeated strikes that wound and weaken them.
Topping removes the top, not the low limbs, and leaves stubs and weak sprouts.
Cables do not reliably hold limbs out of a lane and add hardware to maintain.
A sign does not change the height of the limbs, so trucks keep hitting them.
Question 17 of 18
Mulch piled high against a trunk makes risk assessment harder MAINLY because it:
Reveal the key without answering
A mound of mulch covers the root collar, where girdling roots and basal decay develop, so it has to be pulled back to inspect.
The trunk above the mound can still be sounded.
Mulch at the base does not change whether a failing part would hit anyone.
Mulch adds no strength; piled against bark it keeps it wet and invites decay.
Question 18 of 18
Sounding with a mallet is LEAST reliable for detecting decay:
Reveal the key without answering
A thick sound shell muffles the change in tone, so decay far from the surface of a large trunk often goes unheard.
In a thin stem wall, hollow or soft wood changes the sound clearly, which is where sounding works best.
Thin or decayed wood at a cavity margin gives a dull, hollow note that sounding picks up readily.
Decay or loose bark just under the surface is what a mallet detects most reliably.
–/18
Your tally on these questions
Only this browser tab keeps it; your picks go nowhere, and closing the tab wipes them.
What the Tree Risk domain asks for
Before the 2022 outline this domain was called Tree Risk Management. The current outline calls it simply Tree Risk.
Page 10 of the outline gives the domain three tasks:
A · Roles: what the owner or manager of a tree, the risk assessor and the arborist doing the work are each responsible for, and explaining risk to people with very different backgrounds and interests.
B · Types of risk: failure of the whole tree or of a part; tripping and slipping; falling leaves, fruit and flowers; and risks with no failure at all, such as damage to structures, blocked signs and sight lines, power lines, allergens, poisonous parts and wildlife.
C · Limited visual assessment and mitigation: the levels of assessment, analysis of the target, the site and the tree, tree stability, mitigation aimed at the tree or at the target, and setting an inspection interval.
Risk is a combination, not a defect
In ISA's approach, a tree's risk combines three things: the likelihood that the tree or a part of it fails, the likelihood that the failed part strikes a target, and the consequences if it does. A defect alone is not a risk. A cracked limb over a fenced-off corner and the same limb over a playground are one defect and two different risks.
Analyzing the target means asking what it is and how often it is there. Analyzing the site means reading soil, drainage and exposure. Analyzing the tree means looking for defects and conditions that make failure more likely, and judging the loads the tree carries.
The method is set out in ISA's Best Management Practices: Tree Risk Assessment, third edition (2025), which replaced the 2017 second edition and is a companion to the A300 standard. The rating method and ISA's assessment form are taught in a separate program, the ISA Tree Risk Assessment Qualification (ISA TRAQ), a qualification earned through a course rather than a certification.
Three levels of assessment
The outline lists three levels, limited visual, basic and advanced, and asks which one a situation calls for. The level it asks Certified Arborist candidates to perform is the first: a limited visual assessment of one tree or a population of trees near specified targets, looking for obvious defects and conditions. Basic and advanced assessments go further; the ISA best management practice cited above covers all three levels.
A resistance drill, often called by the trade name Resistograph, drives a thin needle into the wood and records the resistance it meets. A sonic tomograph sends sound between sensors around the trunk. Instrument tests such as these go beyond a limited visual assessment.
Defects an assessor looks for
Decay and cavities: fungal fruiting bodies, cavities, soft or sunken bark, carpenter ants and termites.
Cracks and unions: cracks along the stem, codominant stems, unions with included bark.
Dead and broken parts: dead branches, hangers caught in the crown, broken tops.
Roots and the root collar: cut or damaged roots, soil heaving or cracking opposite the lean, decay at the root collar.
Lean and form: a lean, especially one that has changed, overextended limbs, poor taper.
Species matter as well. The outline lists species-related patterns of whole-tree and part failure under safe work practices, task B, as part of checking a tree before work begins.
Mitigation and support systems
The outline separates tree-based from target-based measures. Tree-based options include pruning to reduce the load on a weak part, installing a support system, or removing the tree.
The outline names structural support systems among the tree-based measures. ISA's Recognizing Tree Risk brochure describes cabling and bracing as physical support for weak branches and stems that adds strength and stability, and adds that such supports are not guarantees against failure. ANSI A300 (2023) also covers lightning protection, which guards a tree against strikes rather than holding up its structure.
Risk ideas that get crossed
Likelihood of failure or likelihood of impact? The first is about the tree. The second is about the target being in the path when it fails.
A tree risk assessor inspects a tree and what lies within its reach, judges how likely a failure is, how likely it is to strike a target and what the consequences would be, and reports a risk level with options to reduce it and a date for the next inspection.
Is the ISA Certified Arborist exam the same as TRAQ?
No. Tree risk is one domain of the Certified Arborist exam. TRAQ is the qualification ISA awards after its own course and assessment, which teach the full rating method.
What counts as a target in tree risk assessment?
Anything of value that a failed tree or part could strike, such as people, vehicles, buildings and utilities.